Lavender's AP Lit Class Blog

Lavender's AP Lit Class Blog

Thursday, October 21, 2010

Hester and Dimsdale are very similar hypocrites. To most people in Boston they are very good on the outside. They think that Dimsdale is a very good minister. The way he speaks inspires them all. Hester is also viewed as a good person. The people think that she has been purified by the scarlet letter. The two of them are very different on the inside than they are on the outside. Dimsdale is dying because of his secret about his affair with Hester. He is also being eaten up by the fact that he cannot help Hester and Pearl. Hester on the inside is very depressed. She has ideas about feminism that were unheard of in her time. Dimsdale’s hypocrisy is worse than Hester’s. In Boston at that period of time the citizens would have thought that Hester’s ideas were far worse than Dimsdale’s sin. Now, quite the opposite is true. Although neither would technically be considered illegal, Dimsdale hiding what he did is far worse than having ideas about feminism. This is because most people in the world give each other freedom to have their own thoughts.

3 comments:

  1. I totally agree with you. I think the town is looking only at Dimmesdale and Hester on the outside. Everyone in the town really has no idea what is going on, because they refuse to look deeper than their looks.

    ReplyDelete
  2. i like how hipocracy is such a strong theme in this book. i think that it is something that everyone struggles with. it also shows that not everyone is perfect and the people that you think so highley of are not actually what you think they are.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Mitch,

    It's good that you've picked up on this central dynamic (the notion of a disconnect between one's inward and outward appearance--but I wonder, do we really consider Hester a hypocrite in the same way we do Dimmesdale? This might be an interesting avenue to explore in your next essay!

    ReplyDelete