Welcome to our 2011-2012 AP Lit. Class Blog! For an overview of what I hope we can achieve through this forum, please see the hand-out ("Notes on Blogging") under the file of the same name on our class web page.
Lavender's AP Lit Class Blog
Tuesday, October 23, 2012
Happiness in the Scarlet Letter
In the Scarlet Letter I believe that only Pearl can be truly happy. I believe this because she is innocent and free from guilt, and as a baby she is described "Whose innocent life had sprung, by the inscrutable decree of providence...out of the rank luxuriance of guilty passion"(173). I believe that since she has not sinned, and that she was only born into sin, she has a chance of being happy. One character who is incable of being happy is Dimmsdale, and the reason is that he is being eaten up by the guilt of his sin. Even from early on in the book we see that he that guilt is devouring him, "Be not silent from any mistaken pity...Than to hide a guilty life."(129) this quote is from the first scaffold seen and it shows us that Dimmsdale is to weak to tell everyone else, but he desperatly wants everyone to know. Then we have Hester, and she is unable to live a happy life because she is in constant reminder of her shame because of the Scarlet Letter, and her daughter Pearl. Even though Pearl reminds her of her sin she is also the only source of happieness Hester has, "But she named the infant "Pearl", as being of great price...her mother's only treasure!"(173). This quote shows that Pearl is the cause of her mothers joy, yet she is also the reason for much of her sadness. And finally Chillingworth is unable to be happy because is so set on revenge he ends up destroying himself. When Dimmsdale says "May god forgive the!...Thou, to hast deeply sinned"(513) This shows that since Chillingworth made it his goal to make Dimmsdale miserable not only has he led a life of sin, but in the after life he will probably not get redemtion.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
fletcher though while pearl is happier than the rest of the people. I do not believe that she is the only one capable of being happy. look at hestger when whe was in the woods with dimsdale. when she threw the scarlet letter away she felt truly happy. or when dimsdale held pearls hand on the scaffold. then he was truly happy
ReplyDeleteAre you saying someone has to be innocent to be happy? Isn't Dimmesdale happy when giving his sermons about religion? He seems to be--at least he enjoys his religion and imparting it to others. Chillingworth seems to be happy torturing Dimmesdale. On page 271 Chllingworth goes crazy with joy after seeing Dimmesdales chest. Maybe you should focus on the different kinds of happienss, like how pearl's is different from Dimmesdales and Chillingworth's.
ReplyDeleteFletcher,
ReplyDeleteI enjoyed discussion your approach to this essay earlier today, and I feel you're very much on the right track (though I'm not sure that I agree wholeheartedly with the comments above--but Jordan does have a point in that you need to define "happiness" early on).